At occasions, being overly optimistic — and glossing over negatives — will be simply as unhealthy as being pessimistic
Final 12 months, throughout a very low section in life, a pal, recognized for her cheery disposition and ever-positive outlook, invited me to stick with her for just a few days. Her intentions have been noble: she didn’t need me to be alone in a susceptible state, and assumed her glad firm would do me a world of excellent. Grateful for her generosity, I agreed.
Sadly, it turned out to be a nightmare. On condition that my points couldn’t be resolved by listening to chants on YouTube or having a glass of bubbly or indulging in infinite chatter, I began withdrawing from conversations together with her. There have been events once I needed to speak, vent out and course of my muddled ideas however, as a substitute, I stored my emotions bottled up as a result of I instinctively knew she wouldn’t perceive.
Someday, the pretence ended as she murmured one thing to the impact of, “In case you preserve speaking about your issues, it’s solely going to extend your stress.” It was my cue to go away. Someway the alleged ‘destructive’ solitude of my residence appeared much more comforting than the precise optimistic bustle of her fancy residence. At residence, at the very least I had the liberty to bawl or be morose or glad, the best way I selected to!
Now, don’t get me incorrect. I’m all for gulping down the positivity tablet. I meditate to manifest my deepest needs, subscribe to Instagram pages like ‘energy of positivity’ and ‘my self-love provide’, like and share each Jay Shetty publish and faithfully kind ‘Sure’ to pop-ups that scream “Happiness is asking, kind Sure to obtain it”.
Sadly, none of them have labored. Once I really feel depressing, I really feel depressing. So, had I forgotten to be glad?
The explanation, as I found just lately, had nothing to do with me. The best way an overdose of something good is unhealthy, positivity has a facet impact too. It’s referred to as ‘poisonous positivity’. And fortunately, there’s a rising realisation that it’s okay to not be glad, courageous and cheerful on a regular basis.
The Secret Syndrome
“Poisonous positivity is the idea that we MUST put a optimistic spin on the whole lot — even tragic or traumatic occasions in life. Of late, there was a rise in poisonous positivity because it has develop into an obsession and habit to many,” observes Dubai-based Yasmen Ahmed, a UK-qualified cognitive behavioural therapist, medical hypnotherapist and NLP practitioner.
Certainly, positivity typically will get prime billing within the ‘the right way to beat stress’ guide. The burgeoning fanbase of Rhonda Byrne’s The Secret and The Magic can be proof of how far the Legislation of Attraction (optimistic ideas convey optimistic outcomes and vice-versa) has come to outline folks’s behaviour. Practising gratitude, not uttering a single destructive syllable and searching for a sliver of silver lining in an in any other case darkish cloud are the keys that many consider will unlock the universe to grant your needs.
To be truthful, these are all unbelievable, scientifically-proven ideas. A 2016 research by Harvard T.H. Chan College of Public Well being revealed that ladies who have been optimistic had a considerably diminished threat of dying from terminal diseases over an eight-year-period, in contrast with ladies who have been much less optimistic. So sure, it’s nice to be optimistic.
However the issue arises, as Dr Saliha Afridi, medical psychologist and co-founder, The Lighthouse Arabia, emphasises, when folks glaze over their life with compelled positivity, and deny, invalidate or dismiss their and others’ difficulties. “When you’re focusing solely on being optimistic, you’re primarily saying there is no such thing as a drawback to be involved with. Truly, some degree of concern is required to ensure that a decision to that drawback,” she notes.
We’re all a part of it
Knowingly or unknowingly, we’re all victims of poisonous positivity. Nasrin Modak Siddiqui, a Mumbai-based journalist, believes the pattern has elevated a lot as a result of the ‘self’ has develop into the centre of our ideas and actions. “The facet impact is that there’s an excessive amount of strain on everybody to remain glad always,” she says.
Nasrin skilled this just lately when an aunt was bedridden with a stroke. “Her being ailing, in one other city, was upsetting sufficient. However the unsolicited recommendation of kin to ‘not stress’ was worse. I consider all of us have completely different inside mechanisms to course of shock and grief and so the recommendation (even when unintentional) may cause undue strain,” she says.
It is very important discuss poisonous positivity as a result of it causes extra hurt than good to these on the receiving finish. “Not sharing genuine, uncooked feelings might make us really feel rejected, invalidated and never seen,” says Yasmen. “This will even not permit others to share their actual feelings.”
A part of the blame lies in social media pages, YouTube channels and WhatsApp forwards that appear to show everybody into pop philosophers who condense options for deep-rooted points into listicles, enjoyable movies and memes. And because it has develop into extra acceptable to eat self-help sources with out the embarrassment hooked up to them like earlier, everybody appears to be tripping on the ‘optimistic vibes solely’ mantra.
“There may be an elevated strain to say ‘I’m high quality’ — through the years, society has concluded that displaying feelings is an indication of ‘weak point’. There’s a thought that since others have it worse, they need to be ‘grateful’ and simply get on with life as a substitute. Saying ‘I’m high quality’ additionally permits us to not dig deeper into our personal feelings, and protects us from feeling ‘uncomfortable’ feelings,” says Yasmen, who typically has shoppers proof against remedy as a result of they consider they’re ‘okay’ (when they aren’t).
Associates, household and the artwork of comfort
Sarcastically, it’s typically household and associates who force-feed optimism and lead you to placing on a smile even while you don’t really feel prefer it. Lisa Brightwell, MD, Vivid Insights Consulting, remembers the time she suffered from post-natal melancholy after she had her daughter. “Everybody anticipated me to be glad as I had a gorgeous child however the actuality of how I felt was completely completely different. Fortunately, I had community round me and was in a position to cope with it however I typically felt I needed to fake all was okay as folks didn’t perceive. Publish-natal melancholy is an actual scenario that ladies need to cope with… You shouldn’t be ashamed of it!” she says.
What makes ‘poisonous optimistic’ folks tough to cope with is that they’re typically well-meaning and genuinely wish to assist. Sadly, they don’t realise that repeatedly parroting, “Don’t stress, it will likely be okay”, “Cease overthinking”, “Don’t be a pessimist” and so forth simply doesn’t minimize it.
That’s the reason why Artur Akopyan, an entrepreneur, prefers to disconnect from the world when he’s beneath stress. “I might fairly watch a comedy movie, listening to Zen music, draw or craft when I’m upset. I don’t cease myself from experiencing actual feelings; I can cry or be offended or mirror on my errors and methods to keep away from them,” he says.
Artur had a poisonous optimistic pal who was ever prepared with options for issues and believed the whole lot would end up good. “Ultimately, it was he who suffered from melancholy. Ever since, I attempt onerous to avoid such folks. For me, an important phrases to say are, ‘I’m with you and we are going to move this collectively’,” he says.
In truth, consoling and displaying empathy is an artwork and a ability. One of the best ways to face by a pal, as Yasmen advises, is to create a secure, non-judgemental house for his or her feelings with out assuming how they’re feeling or telling them how they ‘ought to’ really feel. “Every thing they’re experiencing is legitimate and actual for them,” she says.
Lisa, however, emphasises on compassion. “Chances are you’ll not even have recommendation as typically there may be not loads you’ll be able to say however actions communicate louder. Making them a meal, being current and providing to assist can typically imply extra because the particular person feels you’re there to help them. For me, I at all times really feel higher when an issue is shared with pal or member of the family, typically it simply helps to speak it out or get a hug while you want it!”
Say no to social media
Even in case you are not fortunate sufficient to get a hug or a meal, turning to social media for consolation may very well be the worst factor to do, particularly throughout a pandemic that seems to have fuelled poisonous positivity to excessive limits. Bear in mind the early days of the lockdown when each privileged residence gave the impression to be baking banana bread and each bored influencer or actor did Insta lives to unfold cheer?
Including to the narrative have been self-help gurus and excessive achievers who guilt-tripped you into signing up for programs to upskill your self whilst you struggled to deal with work at home. Their hustle prompted many so as to add a level or two to their resume, however as Covid unfold with elevated dying and untold financial devastation, baking a bread or studying to play the guitar didn’t appear so interesting. As Lisa says, “Throughout the pandemic, I used to be simply attempting to cope with my very own scenario of residence education and dealing from residence. There was no time to consider attempting to be taught a brand new ability or the strain to take action. I used to be simply attempting to maintain my head above water through the week and attempting to loosen up throughout weekends.”
Sadly, seeing celebrities and influencers lead charmed, filtered lives on Instagram day in and time out makes you wish to placed on a present your self. Dr Afridi decodes the phenomenon neatly: “Religious bypassing and/or poisonous positivity existed earlier than social media; nonetheless, social media has performed a serious position in folks feeling like they should current a sure picture to the world. They then have to take care of that picture even on days the place they’re feeling low.” Earlier, we have been evaluating ourselves to our rapid neighbours, associates, co-workers and others that we met. Now our pool of individuals we will evaluate ourselves with is with out boundaries, worldwide, fixed and infinite.
It’s all concerning the cash
In accordance with the International Wellness Institute, the worldwide well being and wellness business is now price $4.2 trillion and it definitely wants optimistic folks to feed into it with instruments and fancy kits to assist the journey. An amused Nasrin remembers getting an uncommon PR present a while again: designer gratitude journals. “The deal was sweetened with half proceeds going to a welfare trigger however actually they have been too fairly to put in writing in. I like journalling however I’m glad to put in writing in my outdated, easy pocket book. I really feel commercialisation has drowned out the noise of actual wellness messages,” she says.
The best way out from OD-ing on positivity is to cope with it similar to every other psychological well being drawback. I requested the specialists to provide just a few ideas. “Step one is to normalise all feelings, even these labelled as ‘unhealthy’. Moreover, give your self time and house to really feel what you’re feeling with out placing a structured or restricted timelines,” says Yasmen.
Dr Afridi stresses on accepting the scenario objectively. “Perceive and settle for nervousness. Identify difficulties and select to deal with ideas and occasions that induce constructive exercise. Problem destructive considering patterns and domesticate a way of humour. Study some problem-solving abilities. Identify your feelings and try for genuine happiness,” she lists. “A life lived nicely could have excessive factors, low factors, failures, disappointments, pleasure and pleasure.” Interact with every second absolutely: no second or emotion lasts without end.”
I used to be reminded of those pointers whereas watching the information rising from India of late. One thing akin to poisonous positivity is going on there. When the nation’s Covid numbers hit the roof and there was all-round criticism of the Indian authorities’s dealing with of the scenario, there was a brand new narrative pushed on social media: the should be optimistic and never deal with deaths and devastation. The federal government, in an obvious bid to stymie criticism, closely promoted the positivity narrative, a lot in order that pleasant organisations organised a “Positivity Limitless” sequence with specialists, influencers and celebrities. Evidently, it backfired.
I suppose, within the Covid period, one of the simplest ways to remain optimistic is to decide on to reside in truth. And never in denial.
(Lekha is a journalist primarily based in India.)
Leave a Reply